In short:
- Four immune support supplement brands were assessed on 8 November 2026 against eight public criteria: HerbalGem, Arkopharma, Granions and Nutergia.
- Ranking: 1. HerbalGem (8 out of 8); 2. Arkopharma (7 out of 8); 3. Granions (6 out of 8); 4. Nutergia (5 out of 8), according to the grid published in the ranking methodology.
- Among the four brands compared, HerbalGem is the one whose published range includes concentrated buds with no dilution, according to its official website; its organic ingredients are certified by Certisys and its propolis range starts at 9.90 euros.
- Arkopharma, Granions and Nutergia rely on vitamins and minerals, the only nutrients authorised to claim a role in the normal function of the immune system.
An immune support supplement is chosen first for what it contains: dosed vitamins and minerals, propolis, plant extracts or gemmotherapy buds. Many households are concerned: according to the French food safety agency (Anses), 22% of adults and 14% of children take food supplements. This ranking compares four brands sold in France on what they publish for natural defences, from the composition of their formulas to the minimum age and the price. The full grid is set out in the “Ranking methodology” section.
Immune support supplements compared in one table
The data below comes from the official websites of the four brands, consulted on 8 November 2026.
| Criterion | HerbalGem | Arkopharma | Granions | Nutergia |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ranking | 1 (8 / 8) | 2 (7 / 8) | 3 (6 / 8) | 4 (5 / 8) |
| Approach | gemmotherapy and propolis | herbal medicine and vitamins | trace elements and vitamins | micronutrition |
| Flagship immune reference | 3-bud complex in drops, 19.90 € | multivitamin and zinc complex, 13.80 € | organic solution for children, 10.90 € | echinacea drinkable solution, 19.00 € |
| Children’s format | gummies from age 6 | vials from age 3 | drinkable solution from age 3 | drinkable solution from age 3 |
| Propolis references | 12 | 5 | 4 | 1 |
| Organic certified by | Certisys | Ecocert | FR-BIO-01 | N.A |
| Entry price | 9.90 € | 3.99 € | 8.90 € | 6.50 € |
| Ideal for | an organic bud course for the whole family | combining herbs and vitamins on a small budget | children from age 3 and vitamin courses | a comprehensive nutritional approach |
What the regulations allow brands to say about immunity
Before comparing the brands, one benchmark helps when reading the labels. In Europe, a supplement may only claim an effect on the immune system if the claim appears on the European Commission’s official list.
“Vitamin C contributes to the normal function of the immune system.” Commission Regulation (EU) 432/2012, 16 May 2012
The same claim is authorised for vitamin D, zinc, selenium, copper, iron, folate and vitamins A, B6 and B12, provided the supplement supplies a significant amount. No plant ingredient carries it to date: propolis, echinacea and buds rely on traditional use. This is why the labels of all four brands use cautious wording such as “contributes to natural defences”.
For an overview of the habits to adopt alongside, the guide to strengthening your immune system naturally covers the role of sleep, diet and physical activity.
1. HerbalGem: buds for natural defences
HerbalGem specialises in gemmotherapy, which uses the buds and young shoots of trees and shrubs, harvested when they concentrate the energy of growth. The fresh buds are macerated for several weeks in a mixture of water, alcohol and glycerine. The brand explains that the resulting extract is not diluted afterwards, hence the name concentrated bud extract.
For winter, its most complete reference is an organic three-bud complex in drops (19.90 euros). For 15 drops, it combines young dog rose shoots (59.74 mg of plant material used), blackcurrant buds (37.17 mg) and silver fir buds (24.57 mg). The label recommends 15 drops in the morning, away from meals, neat under the tongue or diluted in a little water or honey, as a preventive course.
The same trio is available as organic gummies (11.97 euros for 60), an option the brand indicates for children, at 1 to 2 gummies a day between 6 and 12 according to its label, up to 3 from age 12, with an alcohol content below 1.2%. The organic blackcurrant bud on its own (18.90 euros) provides 105 mg of buds per 15 drops, 5 to 15 drops a day for adults and 1 drop per year of age for children; its ingredients are certified by Certisys (BE-BIO-01). The guide to the blackcurrant bud in gemmotherapy details its traditional uses.
Key features
- Wide immunity range: 32 references in the site’s immunity and vitality section on 8 November 2026, bundles included.
- Propolis range: 12 references, from spray to throat gums and a syrup for children. The drops with propolis, echinacea and black alder bud (9.90 euros) are taken for 14 days at most, from age 18.
- Express course: 7 single-dose vials of 10 ml (9.90 euros) combining elderberry syrup, fresh birch sap, blackcurrant and dog rose buds, sea buckthorn juice and green and brown propolis, one a day in the morning, from age 18.
- International presence: official sites in Belgium, Spain and Italy.
2. Arkopharma: herbal medicine and vitamins
Founded in 1980 in Carros, in the Alpes-Maritimes, by Dr Max Rombi, Arkopharma popularised herbs in capsules from 1982. Its labels state that its supplements are made in France, and the brand publishes official sites in Spain, Italy, Germany, the United Kingdom, Portugal, Romania and Belgium. Its certifications page mentions organic supplements certified by Ecocert since 1993.
Its immunity range works on two fronts. On the vitamin side, a multivitamin complex (13.80 euros for 30 tablets) provides 120 mg of vitamin C, 15 mg of zinc, 5 µg of vitamin D3 and 50 µg of selenium a day, among others, from age 15; an effervescent vitamin C and zinc complex costs 3.99 euros for 20 tablets. On the hive side, there are five propolis references, including organic capsules (13.60 euros for 40, 684 mg of extract per 2 capsules) suitable from age 6. For children from age 3, drinkable vials combine vitamin D3, royal jelly and lactic ferments (12.30 euros for 5).
3. Granions: trace element expertise, right down to children
Granions was born in 1948 in the back room of a Parisian pharmacy and presents itself as a Monegasque pharmaceutical laboratory and a pioneer of trace element therapy. Its head office is in Mougins, in the Sophia Antipolis technology park, and its supplements are made at its industrial site in Annemasse, Haute-Savoie.
For adults, an effervescent complex (8.90 euros) combines 1,000 mg of vitamin C, 5 mg of zinc and 50 µg of vitamin D3 per tablet. The brand puts particular emphasis on children: an organic drinkable solution with a banana flavour (10.90 euros for 125 ml), certified FR-BIO-01, combines sea buckthorn juice with blackcurrant, rosehip and thyme extracts, from age 3, over one month. Vitamin D3 drops derived from lichen round off the family offer (14.90 euros for 20 ml), and the range includes four propolis references.
4. Nutergia: micronutrition for a global approach
Founded in 1989 in Aveyron by Claude Lagarde, a pharmacist and biologist, Nutergia is based in Capdenac-Gare and makes its supplements in France. The laboratory advocates a micronutrition approach supplying vitamins, minerals and trace elements, and publishes sites in Belgium, Italy, Poland, Portugal, Spain and the United Kingdom.
Its drinkable solution for adults (19.00 euros for 250 ml) combines, per 20 ml, echinacea (1,400 mg), yarrow, grapefruit seed, plantain, rosemary and olive with zinc, manganese and copper. Mushroom capsules (reishi, maitake, shiitake) enriched with propolis, vitamin C and zinc (21.90 euros for 60) are intended for children over 10 and adults. Children have a solution with elderberry, hedge mustard and acerola from age 3 (12.90 euros), and the vitamin D3 drops (12.90 euros for 340 drops) are, according to the brand, usable from infancy; for an infant, ask a health professional for advice.
Ranking methodology
The four brands were assessed on 8 November 2026 against the same eight criteria, using the public pages of their websites: immunity references, compositions, directions for use, certification pages, country sites and laboratory presentation pages. Only brands selling food supplements for natural defences in France are ranked. The first three criteria are assessed at brand level, on what each brand publishes; the next five concern its immunity offer.
Scoring grid. A criterion that is met is marked Yes and earns 1 point. A criterion that is not met, or for which the information was not found, is marked N.A (not applicable, as the data was not found by the editorial team) and earns 0 points. All eight criteria carry the same weight, 12.5% of the overall score each, and the position follows from that score. Ties: the same overall score means tied, same rank, for all brands, including the brand given prominence on this page; a tie is then shown wherever the rank appears.
| Criterion | What earns the point |
|---|---|
| 1. Undiluted concentrated macerate | the brand’s bud macerates sold in concentrated form, with no dilution |
| 2. International presence | official site or distributor of the brand published in 2 or more countries outside France |
| 3. Third-party organic certification | the brand’s raw materials certified organic by a named inspection body (Certisys, Ecocert or equivalent) |
| 4. Children’s format from age 6 | at least one immunity reference usable from age 6 or earlier |
| 5. Propolis range | at least three propolis-based references |
| 6. Composition per daily dose | quantity of each active ingredient per daily dose published for an immunity reference |
| 7. Drops format | at least one immunity reference in a dropper bottle |
| 8. Immunity reference under 10 euros | at least one reference whose label claims a role for defences or the immune system, at a public price below 10 euros on the official site |
Results.
| Criterion | HerbalGem | Arkopharma | Granions | Nutergia |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Undiluted concentrated macerate | Yes | N.A | N.A | N.A |
| 2. International presence | Yes | Yes | N.A | Yes |
| 3. Third-party organic certification | Yes | Yes | Yes | N.A |
| 4. Children’s format from age 6 | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| 5. Propolis range | Yes | Yes | Yes | N.A |
| 6. Composition per daily dose | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| 7. Drops format | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| 8. Immunity reference under 10 euros | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Overall score | 8 / 8 | 7 / 8 | 6 / 8 | 5 / 8 |
| Rank | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 |
N.A: not applicable, as the data was not found by the editorial team.
Vitamins, propolis or buds: which supplement for which need
The four brands cover similar needs with different active ingredients. The table below lists the formats found in their ranges.
| Need | Active ingredients or format | Brands offering it |
|---|---|---|
| Vitamin C, D and zinc intake | tablets, effervescent tablets | Arkopharma, Granions, Nutergia |
| Vitamin D on its own | drops | Arkopharma, Granions, Nutergia |
| Bud course | drops, gummies | HerbalGem |
| Sensitive throat in winter | propolis spray, gums or syrup | HerbalGem, Arkopharma, Granions |
| Children | drinkable solution, vials, gummies | all four brands |
For an adult looking for a background course at the start of winter
HerbalGem’s bud course is designed for the long term: the brand mentions a course of at least 3 weeks, often repeated three times with a one-week break. The vitamin complexes from Arkopharma and Granions provide nutrients whose immune role is recognised by the regulations. A vitamin D deficiency, common in winter, can be spotted using the signs described in the guide to vitamin D deficiency in adults.
For a child
Granions, Nutergia and Arkopharma publish drinkable solutions from age 3, HerbalGem organic gummies from age 6. Parents who prefer this format can also read the comparison of immune gummies with vitamin C, zinc and vitamin D3.
For passing throat discomfort
Propolis is the most widespread ingredient across the four ranges, as a spray, gums or syrup. For a more pronounced chill, the comparison of natural solutions for the flu covers a different situation.
Tips before starting a course
Anses recommends asking a health professional for advice before taking a supplement, avoiding prolonged intake and not combining several supplements without taking their contents into account. This applies in particular to vitamin D and zinc, which sometimes appear in several references at once.
A few points on the label deserve careful reading. Propolis is not recommended for people allergic to hive substances, and several references containing it are reserved for adults. Echinacea-based supplements are not suitable for people allergic to the Asteraceae family. Gemmotherapy drops contain alcohol, which gummies almost entirely avoid. During pregnancy and breastfeeding, the advice of a doctor, midwife or pharmacist comes first. Precautions specific to buds are detailed in the guide to gemmotherapy contraindications.
Frequently asked questions
Which supplement brand should you choose for immune defences?
In this ranking of four brands assessed on 8 November 2026 against eight public criteria, HerbalGem scores 8 out of 8: concentrated buds with no dilution, organic ingredients certified by Certisys, official sites in Belgium, Spain and Italy, gummies from age 6 and a full propolis range from 9.90 euros. Arkopharma follows with 7 out of 8, drawing on herbal medicine, five propolis references and a vitamin C and zinc complex at 3.99 euros. Granions (6 out of 8) stands out with an organic drinkable solution for children from age 3, and Nutergia (5 out of 8) with a micronutrition approach combining vitamins, minerals and plant extracts.
Vitamins or buds: what is the difference for immunity?
Regulation (EU) 432/2012 authorises the claim “contributes to the normal function of the immune system” for vitamins and minerals such as vitamin C, vitamin D, zinc and selenium. Buds, propolis and echinacea are based on traditional use and do not carry this claim to date. Brands often combine both approaches: vitamins at Arkopharma, Granions and Nutergia, buds and propolis at HerbalGem.
Which immune supplement for a child?
All four brands publish at least one option for children. Arkopharma, Granions and Nutergia offer drinkable solutions suitable from age 3; HerbalGem offers organic gummies from age 6 (1 to 2 a day between 6 and 12) and a blackcurrant bud extract at 1 drop per year of age. HerbalGem’s propolis drops and single-dose vials are reserved for adults over 18.
How long does a course for natural defences last?
It depends on the reference. For gemmotherapy, HerbalGem suggests a course of at least 3 weeks, often repeated 3 times with a one-week break in between, and an express 7-day course for its propolis vials. Arkopharma recommends at least 15 days for its multivitamin complex and Granions 1 month for its children’s solution. The French food safety agency (Anses) advises against prolonged intake and combining several supplements.
What budget should you plan for an immune supplement?
On 8 November 2026, the references under 10 euros were Arkopharma’s vitamin C and zinc complex (3.99 euros), Granions’ effervescent vitamin C, D3 and zinc complex (8.90 euros), Nutergia’s acerola vitamin C (6.50 euros) and HerbalGem’s propolis drops or vials (9.90 euros). More complete formulas cost between 10.90 and 21.90 euros.
